Back in 2011 I spent a summer in Ohio working as a front gate photographer at Cedar Point. It was one of the best summers of my life, and introduced me to a whole host of American candy and treats. Step in the turtle candy; a cluster of pecans, enrobed with caramel and covered in chocolate. I had turtle fudge, turtle ice cream, turtle brownies…the list goes on! Its just the perfect combination, and turtle cookies are my favourite.
The recipe makes an abundance, which believe me is not a bad thing! The turtle cookies are so moreish its unreal and they’re the perfect accompaniment to a cup of tea. They’re also quite therapeutic to make, as you roll, dip and roll again. Though it does make for messy hands!
You’ll need to set aside some time for these as you need to chill the dough in the fridge for an hour before you begin the rolling process. Creating the classic rugged effect around the edge of the turtle cookies is actually pretty simple. Firstly you’ll need to roll the dough into balls before dipping them in to frothy egg whites, this acts as the ‘glue’ when you roll the dough balls into crushed pecans. Finally, once you’ve placed the balls onto a baking tray you need to create the dent with the back of a spoon for your delicious salted caramel filling. Its as simple as that!
Now the salted caramel filling is actually the biggest cheat of them all. It’s simply melted toffee sweets with double cream and a big pinch of sea salt flakes on top- so sue me! But it works so well and makes for a deliciously chewy filling to the turtle cookie. Turtle candies don’t usually use salted caramel, but I thought it balanced out the whole cookie so well and added a different dimension of flavour.
I really love the simplicity of this recipe, especially considering how delicious the turtle cookies are! Let me know if you make them, or are also a turtle fan!